Key Concepts
Discrete step: An action with one right answer that produces the same result every time. It does not benefit from your expertise or context.
Judgment work: Work that depends on a human to make a decision. It runs on pattern recognition, business context, and experience. Two people who both know the job could disagree and both be defensible.
Quick Reference
Two questions to sort any step
- Discrete test: Could a competent stranger follow your written instructions and land where you would land, without asking you anything? If yes, it is discrete.
- Judgment test: Could two people who both know this job reach different answers and both be defensible? If yes, it is judgment.
Examples from the weekly report
- Discrete:
- Export the data
- Compare the columns
- Pull every page that dropped more than five points
- Format the message
- Post it to Slack
- Judgment:
- Is this drop a real threat?
- What is the competitor doing?
- Should we respond at all?
- Is this brief good enough to send?
Warning sign in your own writing
- If the only instruction you can write is “flag it if it looks serious,” you have found a judgment step. The glance that tells you a number is a problem draws on context the report does not contain, such as a competitor launch, which page drives demo requests, and whether this drop is noise.
Why sorting pays off
- Typical split: roughly 80% of time goes to discrete steps and 20% to judgment.
- Example: a report that takes two and a half hours, with 30 minutes of judgment at the end. Hand over the discrete half and let it run overnight, so your 30 minutes land where your judgment matters most.
- Every hour spent on the discrete half is an hour not spent on the half only you can do.
Benchmark: MongoDB
- Problem: Engineers spent hours hunting for content fixes instead of making them. Judgment was never the bottleneck. Finding the work was.
- Agent 1: Aggregates citations, so the team can report on what Builder Relations, SEO, PR, and Community each contribute.
- Agent 2: Recommends schema markup updates.
- Human role: Neither agent decides anything. They produce first drafts, and a subject matter expert reviews before anything happens to them.
- Result: Engineers spend 30% less time on it.